Saharawi organisations slam EU over trade talks with Morocco
"Seeking to circumvent the ECJ’s ruling, directly challenges the credibility of the EU, and significantly damages the potential for progress through the UN-led negotiation process", Saharawi groups qualify the EU's talks with Morocco regarding Western Sahara trade, in their letter to the EU's Foreign Affairs Chief.
In December 2016, the highest Court of the EU ruled that no EU trade or association agreement with Morocco could be applied to Western Sahara, and that the people of the territory have to consent to any arrangement affecting them. But the Union wishes to continue importing products from Western Sahara and has now resorted to talks with Morocco - thereby completely ignoring the very essence of the Court ruling; Western Sahara is "a distinct and separate territory" .
Saharawi organisations from the occupied territory and from the Algerian-based refugee camps have now written a letter to the EU's Member States Foreign Affairs Ministers, and EU Foreign Affairs Representative Federica Mogherini, asking the EU to "cease its attempts to circumvent the ECJ ruling, and instead focus on actions that will support Saharawi people in our legitimate aim of self-determination and democracy".
Foreign Ministers of the European Union Federica Mogherini, High Representative for Foreign and Security Policy, 29 August 2017
We write to you as representatives of Saharawi civil society in response to recent EU attempts to amend its trade agreement with Morocco underpinned by the illegal exploitation of natural resources of Western Sahara, and to dispel the myth that this exploitation benefits the local Saharawi population. This process has taken place entirely in the absence of any consultation with Saharawi voices. As representatives of Saharawi civil society organizations based in the occupied Territory of Western Sahara and the refugee camps in the Southwest Algerian desert, we call on the EU to cease all trade talks with the occupying power, Morocco, regarding resources and trade in Western Sahara.
On 21 December 2016, the European Court of Justice joined the ranks of the ICJ, the United Nations and the African Union in upholding the long-standing and unequivocal position that Morocco has no sovereignty over Western Sahara. The ECJ determined that the Saharawi people have an inalienable right to self-determination. And crucially, it confirmed our right to protect and preserve our interests in the natural resources of our territory and waters. That decision reaffirmed that any agreement pertaining to Western Sahara’s natural resources requires the consent of the Saharawi people, who are represented by the Front POLISARIO, as General Assembly Resolution 34/37 established in 1979.
Against this background, it is appalling that the EU is now seeking to identify ways to bypass the ruling of its very own court. Our organizations have been on the ground throughout the conflict, we have seen first-hand that the illegal exploitation of our natural resources solely benefits Morocco; which occupies part of our land and commits human rights violations against our people. The facts on the ground are clear regardless of any commitments that you may receive from the Moroccan state. For example, in partnership with energy companies, including European firms such as Siemens and Enel, the Moroccan royal family has generated an estimated €143.4 million from the illegal exploitation of Western Sahara’s natural resources. The Saharawi people have not benefited at all monetarily from this trade or from funds “reinvested” into the Territory.
The Moroccan state-owned phosphate giant OCP, promised the creation of jobs in its mining operation in Western Sahara. These positions, however, overwhelmingly go to Moroccan settlers, whose presence in occupied Western Sahara is heavily subsidized and supported by the Moroccan State. Jobs are largely unavailable to Saharawis, who are oppressed, denied opportunities, and treated as second class citizens in our own land.
These are only a handful of examples of how the illegal exploitation of the Western Sahara only benefits Morocco and further entrenches Rabat’s illegal occupation of Saharawi territory. Enabling further exploitation by seeking to circumvent the ECJ’s ruling directly challenges the credibility of the EU, and significantly damages the potential for progress through the UN-led negotiation process, which is the appropriate framework through which to resolve the issue of natural resources. Many EU Member States vigorously support the political process under the auspices of the UN Security Council and the work of the new UN Envoy, former German President Horst Köhler. It is time that EU Member States back up their approach in New York with a consistent and complementary approach in Brussels.
Your excellencies, international law is very clear that any agreement concluded with Morocco cannot apply to Western Sahara or be implemented in any way that allows its territory, territorial waters or resources to be used in any way without the consent of the Saharawi people through their internationally recognized representatives, the Front POLISARIO. Any attempt to alter this reality will be challenged again at the ECJ, and will only see EU efforts wasted in the courts as instead of playing a constructive role in a viable political process.
We therefore request that the EU cease its attempts to circumvent the ECJ ruling, and instead focus on actions that will support Saharawi people in our legitimate aim of self-determination and democracy.
Please accept, your excellencies, the assurances of our highest consideration.
1. Lahcen Dalil – Association for Monitoring of Resources and for Protection of the Environment in Western Sahara (AMRPENWS) 2. Sidi Mohamed Dadesh – Saharawi Committee for the Defense of the Self-Determination of the People of Western Sahara (CODAPSO) 3. Dahan Brahim – The Saharawi Association for Victims of Grave Violations Committed by the Moroccan State (ASVDH) 4. Aminatou Haidar – Sahrawi Human Rights Defenders (CODESA) 5. Bachri Bentaleb – The Sahrawi Association for the Protection and Dissemination of the Saharawi Culture and Heritage 6. Ahmed Tanji – Media Team 7. Mahmoud Elhaissan – National Television Team 8. Salma Limam – The Sahrawi Center for Media and Communication 9. Faddah Aghlamanhom – The Association for the Protection of Sahrawi Prisoners in Moroccan Prisons 10. Ali Salem Babit – Committee for Support the Peace Plan and Protection of Natural Resources in Western Sahara 11. Nhabouha Lakhlifi – Committee of the Mothers of the 15 Abductees 12. Ibrahim El–Haj – Association for Justice and Human Rights. 13. Rokaya Al-Hawasi – The Saharawi Center for Save Memory 14. Fatimato Bara – The Sahrawi Observatory for the Child and Women 15. Soukaina Jadahlou – Forum for the Future of Women 16. HAMZA Filali – Renunciation Moroccan Nationality Group 17. Mahfoud Dahou – Bentili Media Center 18. Sidi Mohamed Alawat – Ibsar Al Khair Association for the Disabled in the Western Sahara 19. Lahbib Salhi – Gdim Izic Coordinating for Peaceful Movement 20. Saleh El Zigam – Committee of Victims of the Agdaz and Magouna 21. Sidi Sbai – Independent Media Commission 22. Al Hussein Al Nasseri – The Sahrawi Association for Persons with Disabilities in Western Sahara 23. Saleh Anoueni – Committee of the Families of the Sahrawis Missing 24. Sultana Khaya – The Sahrawi Association for the Defense of Human Rights and the Protection of resources in Bujdour 25. Hammadi Nassiri – Freedom Sun Organization in Smara 26. Fakkou Lahbib – Sahrawi Committee for the Defense of Human Rights in Samarra 27. Mami Omar Salem – Organization Against in Dakhla
Morocco occupies the major part of its neighbouring country, Western Sahara. Entering into business deals with Moroccan companies or authorities in the occupied territories gives an impression of political legitimacy to the occupation. It also gives job opportunities to Moroccan settlers and income to the Moroccan government. Western Sahara Resource Watch demands foreign companies leave Western Sahara until a solution to the conflict is found.
It's not easy keeping up with all the different legal proceedings relating to Western Sahara. For the sake of clarity, here's an overview of the five different cases at the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Leading activists from Western Sahara are condemned to sentences ranging from 20 years to life imprisonment in connection to a mass protest in 2010 denouncing the Saharawi people’s social and economic marginalization in their occupied land; the Gdeim Izik protest camp.
At COP22, beware of what you read about Morocco’s renewable energy efforts. An increasing part of the projects take place in the occupied territory of Western Sahara and is used for mineral plunder, new WSRW report documents.